My head nearly exploded into a million pieces earlier this week when my good friend Ben Cunningham sent me an article titled, “Let’s Nationalize Amazon and Google.” I’m not even going to link to the main article to spare you the brain rot, but you can…ahem, Google it if you want to find it. I will, however, run counterpoint to the asinine article’s main arguments from rendering unto Caesar these tech giants: These companies’ existence is thanks to the government-created Internet, so the government has a right to all they’ve built thereafter. Giving government exclusive control over everything that derived from the Internet—or anything else it happened to have a hand in creating—would lead the entire world back into the stone ages, and innovation would be annihilated. And under that same logic, can the private sector then take back everything that it created from the grasp of government? Healthcare, education, professional licensing, our sports teams (and their names), just to name a few. Google and Amazon are necessities without which we cannot live. My wife will tell you that I’m an Amazon junkie (I bought nails online this week to avoid the store), so I can empathize with the whole necessity angle. But in economics, public goods must be (a) non-excludable, meaning that freeloaders can use them even without paying, and (b) non-rivalrous, meaning that if one person consumes or uses the good, it doesn’t reduce the good for another. National defense is perhaps the best example of a public good. If you don’t pay taxes, you still benefit from our military; and your “use” of national defense doesn’t reduce its availability for someone else to use. Under no circumstances could Google and Amazon be considered public goods and thereby subject to exclusive control of the government. I can’t just take toilet paper or shoes from Amazon without paying, and when I purchase those things, someone else can’t have them. It fails the public good test, no questions asked. They’re at near monopoly status and they abuse their power. Yeah, so let’s turn them over to government where they will be true monopolies and have the force of law to abuse their power even further. Would you conduct your personal searches on IRS.com? Do you really believe that package is going to arrive on time when you use the Post Office over FedEx? If so, then sure, let’s make Google and Amazon public utilities. They got tax breaks and handouts in their quest for world domination. I’m going to actually agree with this criticism, though not the ultimate solution. Companies should not get special treatment like tax incentives or handouts. But because they do does not entitle the government to take them over…or does it? Maybe companies should be wary of all those incentive packages, lest they let the government creep too far into their operations. It’s like an iron fist inside a velvet glove. Again, if you want to actually read the article, Google it while you still can. Given the recent rollout of Healthcare.gov, once we have Google.gov, you’ll probably have a tough time turning up the right search results. -Justin Owen Enjoy the Beacon blog? Help us keep it going with a tax-deductible gift.
KEEP IN TOUCH WITH US
LATEST POSTS
Beacon Poll: July 2024 Results
Today, we released our next installment of the Beacon Poll, a statewide survey of 1,200 registered Tennessee voters comprised of questions a...
Instant Reaction to Chevron Decision
Today’s Supreme Court decision overturns Chevron and returns the task of interpreting laws to the courts. That’s a great thing for liberty.
The ESSER Fiscal Cliff: Expiring Federal Relief for Schools and Potential Tax Increases
In the coming months, county commissioners will be taking up school board budgets. These discussions and votes are an annual occurrence, tho...
Net Neutrality: A Costly Solution in Search of a Problem
Regulators should match their rules with reality and in the case of Net Neutrality, that’s clearly not happening.
It’s Time for Tennessee: Double-Digit States Offer Universal Education Freedom
With dozens of states providing choice programs and a growing number providing the same options to all students, Tennessee policymakers must...
Red Light, Yellow Light, Green Light: A “Choose How You Move” Breakdown
What to make of Nashville's new transit plan? We’ve got you covered.
Beacon Files Supreme Court Brief to Defend Equality Under the Law
Many Tennesseans benefitted from fresh starts in education and enterprise. Many more would also benefit if the government stopped discrimina...
Music City: No Home for Music—An Excerpt from “Modern Davids”
Due to their grassroots activism, Lij and Pat convinced the city council to soften the home business ban.
KEEP IN TOUCH WITH US
WANT TO DO A STORY ABOUT SOMETHING YOU SEE HERE?
CONTACT US AT:
mark@beacontn.org
(O) 615-383-6431
WHO ARE WE?
The Beacon Center of Tennessee empowers Tennesseans to reclaim and protect their freedoms, so that they can freely pursue their version of the American Dream.